Sensitivity
This essay was written with heavy use of AI. Exactly how is disclosed at the end.
A sensitive person eats bread. They take in its smell, its texture, its shape. “The butter is different from yesterday’s. It proofed less than usual. The shaping is finer than yesterday’s.” All that sensing and reading can be a pleasure. All that sensing and reading can be tiring. The pleasure and the fatigue come from the same bread. Both arrive before any choosing. What can be chosen comes after. Which one to stay with, whether to say it or swallow it. If they say what came to mind in the bakery, they may be told they are being oversensitive and shown the door. They may be thanked for saying so and handed a cookie. Whether to speak can be chosen. The baker’s response cannot.
A less sensitive person eats bread. “It’s bread.”
An infant’s senses
A newborn is sensitive to everything. Every sound is a first, every light is a first. At six months an infant can tell apart the speech sounds of a language it has never heard, and can tell one monkey’s face from another. Around its first birthday it loses those sounds, and all monkey faces become the same face. The distinctions in use are kept; the ones not in use get lumped together. Dulling is not damage. It is learning.
So sensitivity is not a specification of the few but everyone’s starting point. A sensitive adult is not someone who has something extra. It is someone who has dulled less.
A distinction survives by one of two roads. The ones kept in use because they gave pleasure survive, and the ones that could not be dropped without getting hurt survive. The discrimination of the gourmet and the discrimination of the alarm.
Distinctions do not only dull. Among the discriminations of the alarm there is a branch that gets honed. A hand that remembers a burn and stays on guard draws back even from what is merely warm.
Whichever road it came by, the pattern has something in common. Whether sensitivity turns out a curse or a blessing, whether others welcome it or shut it out, does not depend on the sensitivity itself.
Time
A sensitive person reads more of the same world and gathers more from the same day. In that sense they live a longer life in the same ten years.
That is why childhood stays long. A year full of firsts is intricate and long when you look back. A year with fewer firsts, looked back on, has its days clumped together without distinction, and the whole year shrinks to a few scenes.
Suppose two people living through the same span of time.
The first has their senses reset every day. Memory stays. They begin each day with an infant’s senses. A stimulus met for the first time is strange. That strangeness returns every day. Dense.
The second accumulates their senses with no reset. They begin each day carrying what they felt the day before. A stimulus met yesterday is familiar. Repeated, it becomes habit. Seasoned.
The first person’s ten years are denser, longer, heavier. A sensitive person stands between the two, nearer the first. Whether that time is fun or fatigue is a separate matter.
The instrument
There is an instrument whose strings are drawn taut and whose soundboard is thin. Not a slack-stringed instrument that has to be pulled hard to make a sound, but one that sounds at the brush of a fingertip.
A taut string gives different sounds for minute differences, and once set trembling it trembles long. A slack string holds no pitch. A thin soundboard carries even a small tremor large. What has once sounded does not die down easily.
The same trait does other work too. An instrument that sounds at a fingertip also sounds at a passing wind. A sound that lingers lets the unwelcome sound linger too. At a single passing wind the instrument cries and tosses all night. A taut string snaps easily, and a thin soundboard is the first to warp in the damp.
Thicken the board and it sounds less, to the wind and to the fingertip alike. The fineness that gave a different sound for fingertip and for fingernail goes, the creaking through the night goes, and it becomes a different instrument from before. You cannot keep the fineness and remove only the noise.
There is one more way to make it quiet. Loosen the strings and it does not sound in the wind. But the wind blows even on loosened strings. A loosened string is not silent in the wind; it trembles without pitch. The trembling does not go away. Only the sound and the note go. And a loosened string gives no note to the fingertip either. With no resonance, no fingertip can draw any note from it.
The senses
Someone is shown a white wall and asked whether it is clean. Ninety-nine say yes, and one says there is a speck over there. Sensitivity sees the small speck first. It smells what has gone off first. It reads the wilting leaf and the signs of a sick animal first.
The same eye sees other things too. It finds geometry in the veins of a fallen leaf and stops. The ear that hears a note out of place in a celebrated symphony is also the ear that hears harmony in birdsong.
The eye that sees the speck and the eye that sees the grain are the same eye.
The actor
Suppose a person of high emotional reactivity becomes an actor. For that person, the very fact that emotion moves widely is the instrument. They shake their own heart with a life read off a script, and the audience comes to watch that shaking.
A large amplitude leaves a large reverberation. It happens to that actor that the role does not leave after the curtain falls. Reduce the response and the reverberation shrinks. So does the resonance that reaches the seats.
The stage does not cancel this price. It exchanges that price for gold instead.
The room
An instrument needs a room to become music. The same resonance is a performance in a concert hall and noise in an office. Whether the baker throws you out or gives you a cookie does not depend on the tongue of the one who ate the bread.
Here are three names the room gives the instrument.
Siren. An alarm that reads and speaks. When the siren reads danger and sounds, people take cover. It is the seat where the sound is believed.
Cassandra. The seat of one who read and spoke, and whose sound was not received. No one believed the prophecy that Troy would fall. The prophecy came true, and when it did there was no city left to listen. The difference between the siren and Cassandra is not the accuracy of the sensing but the reception. Sensitivity, when received, stays as acuity; when not received, as oversensitivity.
Lightning rod. The seat of one who reads and takes the danger in the others’ place. The person who feels first the signal no one else feels reacts first, and the one who reacts first becomes the problem. The organization’s danger is grounded through that person, and that person takes the danger instead of the organization. With a lightning rod, the organization can get past a danger without ever seeing when it came or what it was. A lightning rod does not stop lightning. It is a device that draws the strike to itself so that it does not fall elsewhere.
The room’s treatment also divides by money. An eighteenth-century English physician wrote that the diseases of the nerves were the diseases of the refined and the wealthy. He said the disease came only to those of the most delicate sensation, and did not come to the dull. That physician, too, likened the nerves to an instrument. The same trembling was, in one class, proof of delicacy. When resonance fetches a price it is music and talent; when it does not, it is noise and symptom.
The room’s treatment also divides by direction. The one who sees the wilting leaf first waters the plant, and the one who hears the animal’s whimper first takes it to the vet. When that eye is on the caring side, it is useful. When it is on the cared-for side, it is high-maintenance.
Diagnoses
Among the names the room has given, some are names of illness.
Melancholia had two readings. There is an ancient text that asks why all those who became outstanding in philosophy, statecraft, poetry, and the arts are melancholics, and Dürer engraved Melancholia as a winged woman, chin on her fist, compasses in hand. All that while melancholia was a disease of the humours, and long afterward it remained a diagnosis. Seeing deeply because of sensitivity and sinking because of it sat under one name, and that name was open to both readings, genius and illness. Because the genius reading existed, there was a way for the sinking side, too, to be read as the price of genius.
Hysteria had one reading. Under that name sat paralyses, convulsions, and mutism for which no cause could be found, and emotion in general that had been judged excessive. A hospital in Paris put those patients before a lecture hall every week, and among the doctors came journalists, writers, and actors to watch. In 1980 the name lost its place as a diagnosis in the American classification and was scattered into several other names. Unlike melancholia, it was a name that, inside medicine, never had a reading as talent.
The same instrument was priced differently according to the name it was filed under.
There was also a name that moved. Soldiers back from the trenches showed paralysis, tremor, mutism. The trench honed whoever was in it, without choosing. The trench could not be called the illness. The army called it cowardice, and there were soldiers shot on that charge. Soldiers and medical officers called it shell shock. The name came from the hypothesis that the shell had shaken the brain. As the patients multiplied and the name came to be seen as a ticket out of duty, the army in 1917 barred that name, too, from use as a diagnosis. The price was written against the person, then against a thing called a shell, and in the end lost its name. It was never written against the trench.
Measurement
There are studies that have tried to measure sensitivity.
When the senses of people who report themselves sensitive are actually measured, they do not hear fainter sounds or catch fainter smells. How sensitive people said they were and the thresholds of their sense organs went separate ways. Sensitivity was not measured by the height of the threshold.
Measurement has also split sensitivity in two. The side that notices subtle things and the side that is shaken hard. In one study the two ran independently. That means many people have only one. But look at the questionnaire items that divided the two sides: on one side the items pair sensitivity with a positive evaluation (“notice and enjoy delicate scents”) and on the other with a negative one (“made uncomfortable by loud noises”). Whether that line divides the amplitude of the resonance or divides its evaluation was not measured. The side this measurement counted as bad overlaps with one dimension of the personality tests. That dimension’s name came from the hospital. Neuroticism.
Words
Korean has sorted what sensitivity does into separate words. The sensor is called nunchi. To have nunchi is the instrument’s specification; to catch nunchi is a single capture; to watch nunchi is to keep reading.
And there is singyeong-eul sseuda and singyeong-i sseuida: to spend one’s nerves on something, and for one’s nerves to get spent on it. The first is something one does; the second is something that happens. The phrase for switching one’s nerves off attaches only to the first. What gets spent on its own cannot be switched off by oneself, so one says it to others: make it so my nerves don’t get spent on this.
Neither the watching nor the nerves getting spent switches off for the wanting. The fatigue of a sensitive person is the fatigue of reading.
The ledger
The price of sensitivity exists. The instrument that sounds at a fingertip sounds at the wind too, a long life is heavy, and a large amplitude leaves a large reverberation.
The question that remains is under whose name that price is written.
In the first chapter of Renard’s Poil de carotte, someone is needed to go out at night and shut the henhouse door. The brother says he is not there to look after hens, and the sister says she would be too frightened. The mother sends Poil de Carotte. He says that he is frightened too. A big boy like you, the mother answers, and the brother and sister chime in: he isn’t afraid of anything. Poil de Carotte crosses the yard trembling, shuts the door, and comes back. He is proud and waits to be praised. The brother and sister go on reading. The mother says: from now on you will go and shut them every evening. The child who said he was afraid is written down as the child who fears nothing. It is a name given in the direction that makes the household comfortable.
The name “sensitive” is often given the same way. The price the household should have paid becomes the child’s name, the price the trench should have paid becomes the soldier’s name, and the price the organization should have paid becomes the lightning rod’s name. The price is real. Writing that price down as a person’s defect is not an observation but an assignment.
The benefit gets names too. Acuity, sensibility, keenness. Those names are also given by the room. They are given in a room where sensitivity fetches a price. And the benefit and the price are often written under different names. The shut henhouse door becomes the household’s, and the fear becomes the child’s. What sensitivity yields becomes the room’s, and the pain becomes the instrument’s.
Back to the instrument. An instrument that sounds at the brush of a fingertip is hard to handle, needs tuning often, and cannot be left in just any room. Thicken the board and it is easy to handle and gives a blunt sound. Loosen the strings and it is quiet and gives no sound at all. An instrument does not choose its own specification. It does not choose the room it is placed in either. An instrument cannot walk. A person can.
References
- Werker, J. F., & Tees, R. C. (1984). Cross-language speech perception: Evidence for perceptual reorganization during the first year of life. Infant Behavior and Development, 7(1), 49–63.
- Pascalis, O., de Haan, M., & Nelson, C. A. (2002). Is face processing species-specific during the first year of life? Science, 296(5571), 1321–1323.
- James, W. (1890). The Principles of Psychology, ch. 15.
- Aron, E. N., & Aron, A. (1997). Sensory-processing sensitivity and its relation to introversion and emotionality. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 73(2), 345–368.
- Eysenck, H. J. (1944). Types of personality: A factorial study of seven hundred neurotics. Journal of Mental Science, 90(381), 851–861.
- Gubler, D. A., Ertl, M., Janelt, T., Roth, M., & Troche, S. J. (2026). Sensory processing sensitivity (SPS) is not a sensory ability: Examining the relationship of SPS with objectively and subjectively measured sensory sensitivity. Journal of Research in Personality, 123, 104730.
- Evans, D. E., & Rothbart, M. K. (2008). Temperamental sensitivity: Two constructs or one? Personality and Individual Differences, 44(1), 108–118.
- Pseudo-Aristotle. Problemata, XXX.1.
- Cheyne, G. (1733). The English Malady.
- Wessely, S. (2006). The life and death of Private Harry Farr. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 99(9), 440–443.
- Jones, E., Fear, N. T., & Wessely, S. (2007). Shell shock and mild traumatic brain injury: A historical review. American Journal of Psychiatry, 164(11), 1641–1645.
- American Psychiatric Association. (1980). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (3rd ed.).
- Renard, J. (1894). Poil de carotte.
This essay was written out of the records of conversations with an AI, through dialectical engagement between me and the machine, typed with the AI’s borrowed hands.